My Little Bs Have the Big C

A Breast Cancer Blog For Young Women

The Question



I’ve always known he’d ask.  That he’d put two and two together.  I just never imagined that it would be so soon.

Oliver and I were lying in his bed as I was snuggling him to sleep.  At one moment we were talking about his day and with no segue at all he asked me again (he asks me a lot), “Mommy, why did they have to take off your breast?” I gave him my usual answer. “There was something in my breast and if we didn’t get it out, it would have made me very sick.”

Usually, he leaves it at that, or begins to ask my questions about having the surgery, did I feel anything in the surgery, questions about my reconstruction, etc…  I always answer honestly.  But this time, tonight, he asked me the question I have always been dreading.

“Mommy, if they didn’t take away your breast, could you die?”

“Yes. But, they did take my breast and now I’m healthy again.”

I heard him breathe in and out, gently.  He took in that information.  I’m not sure how his little brain processed this because he followed it up with his usual questions. “How did they make you a new breast?” “Were you in pain?” “How long were you in pain?” “Did it make you sad? Do you feel sad now?”

After he asked me all of his questions, he very wisely said, “Wow, that was a big conversation.”

Yes.  Yes it was.

These questions…these questions I never wanted my child to have to ask.  But cancer has made us all age beyond our years

I thought that when Oliver asked me about my cancer and death, I’d feel sad.  That I would ache for him knowing that his mother had faced mortality and that he could be directly affected by this.  But that is not what I feel.  I feel proud of him.  I feel proud that he was brave enough to ask the question.  I feel proud that he is so smart and intuitive, that he could come to this conclusion himself at such a young age.  I’m proud that the weight of this conversation was not lost on him.  He totally gets it.  But I’m most proud that he feels comfortable asking me.

One of the last things I said to him before he fell asleep was, “I know that this was a big conversation.  But I want you to know that I will always tell you the truth. Is that ok?”

“Yes, mommy.”

He turned over, snuggled his back into my chest, and fell asleep.

11 thoughts on “The Question

  1. What a wonderful conversation … you have a fantastic connection with your son that is so important xx

    • Thank you. He had more questions this morning. He woke me up by saying, “Let’s talk about your surgery.” He’s definitely trying to process it all.

  2. Pingback: Weekly Round Up | Journeying Beyond Breast Cancer

  3. Simply beautiful.

    Stay well

  4. Oh, brave mama! I salute you for having this conversation with him. I’m so sorry you’re travelling this journey. Know that there will always be people rooting for you.

  5. Hi Carrie,
    What can I say? Such a touching post. I hate that you and your sweet Oliver must have these conversations. But since you must, let me just say, your description of this one is beautiful. I feel the love and pride you have for him coming through in your words. Truth telling. Such a simple concept. And yet, such a huge one when the topic is cancer. Thank you for sharing about this talk with us. xo

    • Nancy, thank you so much. Oliver has been asking a lot of the same questions over and over. He’s working really hard on processing all of the information. But he loves to snuggle me and announce that we are going to talk about it again. I guess he wants to see if I’m being consistent. I know more questions will follow as he gets older. Thank you for reading!!!

  6. Hi Carrie, I am sorry you had to have this conversation at all. But I know you’ll always do your best as a mom. I admire the fact that you’re being so open with your son. I believe this is the healthiest approach. And thank you for sharing this touching experience with us. xoxo

    • Hi Rebecca, I also think honesty is the best approach. I don’t want him to ever think we are lying to him or that he can’t trust my word. It’s important to me that he feels like he can talk to me. Thank for reading. I hope you are doing well. I have a free summer. We should meet up.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s